Study: Greater greenhouse gas reductions for pickup truck electrification than for other light-duty vehicles

Life cycle greenhouse gas emissions for each vehicle class and powertrain. Average lifetime emissions account for differences in grid emissions for electricity balancing areas and county-level differences in drive cycle and temperature effect on fuel economy. Image credit: From Woody et al. in Environmental Research Letters, 2022

Life cycle greenhouse gas emissions for each individual automobile class and powertrain. Normal life time emissions account for differences in grid emissions for electricity balancing parts and county-stage dissimilarities in generate cycle and temperature influence on gas financial system. Picture credit score: From Woody et al. in Environmental Exploration Letters, 2022

Big automotive makers are ramping up manufacturing of electric vans as a crucial tactic to minimize the greenhouse gas emissions of their autos.

Light-weight-duty autos, which includes sedans, SUVs and pickup vehicles, are now liable for 58% of U.S. transportation sector greenhouse fuel emissions. Pickup trucks accounted for 14% of mild-duty automobile product sales in the United States in 2020, and the market share of both pickups and SUVs has developed in modern a long time.

But what does pickup truck electrification mean for the decarbonization of the transportation marketplace?

University of Michigan and Ford Motor Co. scientists tackled this dilemma in a new examine and evaluated the financial savings in greenhouse gas emissions relative to gasoline-powered pickup trucks. The analyze was published on the internet March 1 in the journal Environmental Exploration Letters.

“This is an important analyze to advise and stimulate local climate action. Our study clearly demonstrates sizeable greenhouse fuel emission reductions that can be attained from transitioning to electrified powertrains across all car or truck lessons,” explained study senior author Greg Keoleian, a professor at the U-M Faculty for Setting and Sustainability and director of the Heart for Sustainable Devices.

In the analyze, researchers done a cradle-to-grave evaluation of the lifestyle cycle of pickup trucks and when compared the implications of pickup truck electrification to all those of sedan and SUV electrification.

With a target on evaluating greenhouse fuel emissions, researchers appeared at three unique model-yr 2020 powertrain options—internal-combustion-motor cars, hybrid-electric powered vehicles and battery-electrical vehicles—for midsize sedans, midsize SUVs and entire-size pickup trucks, accounting for discrepancies in gas economic climate, yearly mileage, car or truck generation and car or truck lifetime across motor vehicle courses.

They discovered that for sedans, SUVs and pickup trucks, battery-electric cars have about 64% decrease cradle-to-grave daily life cycle greenhouse gasoline emissions than internal-combustion-engine autos on typical throughout the United States.

“This analyze can support us to understand the opportunity impression of electrification from an emissions-reduction viewpoint, notably as we introduce new electric powered cars, and how we can continue to speed up our progress in direction of carbon neutrality. We’re proud to husband or wife with U-M in this important operate,” mentioned Cynthia Williams, international director of sustainability, homologation and compliance at Ford.

The examine features several vital findings. Researchers, for occasion, discovered that changing an internal-combustion-motor car with a battery-electric powered automobile outcomes in larger full tonnage of greenhouse fuel emissions reductions as the vehicle dimension will increase, owing to the increased fuel consumption of much larger cars.

Even though the percentage financial savings is about the same across vehicle classes, on common, replacing an interior-combustion-engine sedan with a battery-electric powered sedan saves 45 metric tons of carbon dioxide equivalent changing an interior-combustion-engine SUV with a battery-electrical SUV saves 56 metric tons of carbon dioxide equal and changing an inside-combustion-motor pickup with a battery-electric pickup saves 74 metric tons carbon dioxide equal in excess of the life span of the motor vehicles, reported examine initial author Max Woody, analysis expert at U-M’s Heart for Sustainable Devices.

The researchers also identified that battery-electric powered motor vehicles have larger greenhouse fuel emissions in their manufacturing than internal-combustion-engine vehicles, thanks to battery production, but this impact is offset by discounts in their operation. For battery-electric vehicles and inner-combustion-motor vehicles, the crack-even time is 1.2 to 1.3 yrs for sedans, 1.4 to 1.6 several years for SUVs and 1.3 years for pickup vehicles, based on the typical U.S. grid and vehicle miles traveled.

“This study expands upon earlier reports that have focused on evaluating battery-electric powered car or truck sedans to their internal-combustion-motor or hybrid counterparts,” Keoleian stated. “We report emissions for car or truck output, use and close-of-lifetime stages on a for each-mile foundation and around the overall vehicle life span.

“In addition, we analyzed the regional variation in emissions taking into consideration discrepancies in electrical power grid mixes and ambient temperatures, and we also explored the results of the level of grid decarbonization on emission reduction.”

Vehicle emissions range across the place, as unique temperatures and distinct travel cycles affect a vehicle’s gasoline economic system. For electric powered autos, the greenhouse fuel emissions intensity of the nearby electricity grid is also an important element. The examine made maps to show the lifetime grams of carbon dioxide equivalent/mile for each powertrain (inside-combustion-motor cars, hybrid automobiles and battery-electric powered motor vehicles) and car variety (sedan, SUV and pickup truck) by county across the United States.

Scientists discovered that general public worries about battery-electrical autos owning higher emissions than inside-combustion-engine cars or hybrids are mainly unfounded, as battery-electric cars outperform hybrids in 95%-96% of counties, although battery-electrical vehicles outperform inner-combustion-engine automobiles in 98%-99% of counties, even assuming only modest progress toward grid decarbonization.

Charging tactics can even further decrease battery-electric vehicle emissions. The analyze observed that charging through the hours of the day with the cheapest grid emissions intensity can reduce emissions by 11% on average.

“Deployment of electric vehicles and enlargement of renewable electrical power methods like solar and wind need to be carried out at the exact time,” Woody explained. “The advantage of each individual is improved by the advancement of the other.”

The other authors of the examine are Parth Vaishnav of the U-M University for Surroundings and Sustainability and Center for Sustainable Devices, and Robert De Kleine, Hyung Chul Kim, James Anderson and Timothy Wallington of Ford Motor Company’s Research and Innovation Middle.

The study was supported by Ford Motor Co. through a Ford-College of Michigan Alliance Challenge Award.

Penned by Lori Atherton, U-M College for Setting and Sustainability


Far more data: